Skip to main content

Coffee Cup Research Review #3: Protein intake and body composition


Intro:
            To achieve weight loss with any success, a calorie deficit is necessary. This essentially means to consume less calories than you are expending, typically over the time frame of a day. Although diet composition is debated to have an effect on weight loss, most evidence generally shows little difference for weight loss between different macronutrient breakdowns. This difference could be exaggerated if we go to the extremes, such as with very low carbohydrate diets. In which case there is a greater degree of water loss when removing carbohydrates. Although most fitness professionals tend to agree that more protein in one's diet is generally a good thing. This article shows how that might not necessarily always be the case.



The Nitty-Gritty:

            25 individuals between 18-35 were separated into 3 groups: a low protein group (5% of diet from protein), normal protein (15% protein), or high protein (25% protein). Upon completing a weight maintenance phase of about 2 weeks, participants than were subjected to 8 weeks of over feeding with 40% greater intake. All participants spent the duration of the study in a metabolic unit and had food prepared for them. Participants were not subjected to any physical activity or exercise. 


What Happened / Results: 

- All participants gained weight with no significant differences between sex or race.

- Although, The Low protein group gained on average 3.16kg

- Normal protein group gained 6.05kg

- High Protein group gained 6.51kg


- The difference? Lean body mass (anything except fat/adipose tissue) was -0.70 in low protein, +2.87kg normal protein, 3.18kg in high protein groups. 


- Overeating caused resting energy expenditure to increase for both the normal and high groups. 


-Fat storage between groups was insignificant. All three groups gained nearly the same amount of fat mass.



Takeaway: 

            Diet composition could have an effect for body composition, weight loss, or performance. Protein has a higher thermic effect than both fat or carbohydrate. Meaning essentially that protein is converted to heat to a larger degree than other macronutrients. This suggests that it would be potentially beneficial to increase protein during dieting as it helps to preserve lean mass and promotes satiety (feeling full) as well. It's important to remember not to exclusively rely on the scale when it comes to weight loss. As some of these sedentary subjects even gained some lean body mass. Although this study does not differentiate how much of the increase was due to muscle, water, or bone mass. Having a reliable method of assessing body fat during the weight loss process can be very beneficial. 



Bray GA, Smith SR, de Jonge L, et al. Effect of Dietary Protein Content on Weight Gain, Energy Expenditure, and Body Composition During OvereatingA Randomized Controlled Trial. JAMA. 2012;307(1):47–55. doi:10.1001/jama.2011.1918

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Coffee Cup Research Review #2: Maintaining Weight Loss

Intro: Keeping on the topic of dieting, this time we will be outlining scientifically supported behaviors of successful dieters. The general advice given to people tends to be along the lines of "move more and eat less." It isn't necessarily bad advice. Although what are some more concrete g uidelines we can provide to those trying to lose weight and keep the weight off? The Nitty-Gritty: The Authors of this study observed a few similar behavioral patterns of those who successfully dieted and kept the weight off. Successful weight maintenance post diet was defined as intentionally losing 10% or more of initial bodyweight and keeping it off for at least one year. Information for the study was gathered from the national weight control registry. The registry was predominantly female (80%). Common denominators of successful dieters included: 1. Lower fat and higher carb diets 2. Frequent weight monitoring 3. Food intake monitoring 4. High levels of physical activi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Coffee Cup Research Review #1 : Long Term Hormonal Adaptations to Low Calorie Diets

Intro:  The term “yoyo-dieting” is often referenced when talking about weight regain following a diet. This effect can commonly be observed in many short term, highly restrictive, and very low-calorie diets. Remember that apple cider green tea cleanse your mom did for a week thinking it would tone her stomach? Well what happens when that tea cle anse ends a week later? Humans are creatures of habit and, not surprisingly, tend to fall back into old habits. The-Nitty-Gritty:  The authors of this study observed 50 overweight or non-diabetic patients for a 10- week weight loss program. They then checked back in with patients over a year (62 weeks) later. Several hormones, substances and scores were evaluated but the ones we will focus on will be primarily leptin, ghrelin, and subjective rating of appetite. Participants replaced three daily meals with a diet formula and low starch vegetables (2 cups) for a whopping total of 500-550 calories a day. During weeks 9 and 10, tho...
Post a Comment
Read more

Coffee Cup Research Review: What is it?

This will be an informal research review that will be under 500 words and take 3-5 minutes to read. It will usually involve some important statistics and brief study explanation followed up with a few take away points and a sassy picture of me drinking coffee (because why not).
Post a Comment
Read more